Drilling in Alaska
Gabe Flanagan
As Americans energy is a very important resource for our everyday lifestyle. The United States is known as the most wasteful and resource consuming country in the world, but this problem is not necessarily the fault of the common American citizen. The United States has developed in such ways that in order to keep up with the times and compete with others you must consume these resources. For example: A business is more likely to hire a man who drives to work every day in his/her car and has a cell-phone, rather than the environmentally friendly person who takes public transit and does not have a convenient way to be contacted. This is because a person with these possessions that are not necessarily environmentally friendly will be more dependable. With these growing amount of “necessities” that Americans are expected to have, our usage of natural resources continues to grow. Oil has become the world’s most precious natural resource, and we see this resource becoming scarcer in front of our very eyes. Technology has been developed in order to preserve the world’s supply of oil, but not all of these technologies are useful to all citizens. The blue-collar worker who needs to haul equipment to work each day cannot depend on the engine of a hybrid car to accomplish this task just as the family of six cannot depend on small energy efficient cars such as a prius to fit everyone comfortably. Americans can all agree that this situation of limited supplies of oil, and with countries as large as China becoming more developed by the day, we will someday have to face this crisis, or has it already come? The question becomes to what length Americans will go in order to preserve their energy inefficient lifestyles. The possibility of drilling in Alaska has become a largely debated topic with another oil crisis hanging over American’s heads. When looking at the facts Americans would make money and oil prices would go down, but only for a limited amount of time. Is it worth it to drill for oil in this wildlife refuge if we will only benefit it for a few years?
The earth is not able to sustain a life-promoting climate with the carnage that humans are implementing on the planet. We see this inability to sustain through recent scientific discoveries such as global warming, and other examples of the earth’s responses to our actions. The Arctic National Wildlife Refuge (ANWR) was set up by the United States government in order to protect the specific environment which this area encompasses.
Due to locating of oil fields near and surrounding the ANWR it shows promise of containing large amounts of oil, making it a popular prospect for oil companies. The location of the ANWR is fairly distant from most civilization in Alaska. Many see this as another reason that drilling should be allowed in this area. People fail to remember that this area was protected in order to preserve the environment and animals which thrive there in case of situations such as this where the land was being threatened. Reference
The 16.1 million acres of the ANWR contains roughly about 7.06 billion barrels of oil, approximately the amount that was needed in the United States alone in 2005, a number which has most certainly increased since that time. Reference. It is true that profit would be made from drilling in the ANWR, but is money a good enough reason for Americans to make the decision to drill in a place people have worked so hard to protect? In my opinion, the environmental cost would not equal that of the profit which will be made from drilling in the ANWR.
The ANWR is home to unique wildlife, wilderness, and recreational values and it is not worth it to through away areas such as this away in order to support out gas hungry habits. After the land has been exhausted the ANWR will be left with many roads, refineries and pipelines, all of which will not promote the wildlife and natural habitat that it was designed to protect. As Americans we are expected to be leaders in the world, we should be using this money that we apparently have to set up a method of extraction in Alaska and put it into the development of alternative forms of energy. This process of drilling may benefit us for a year, but then what, we will find ourselves in a similar situation with even more limited possibilities for courses of action. Now is a chance to stand up for the “green revolution” that so many Americans claim to support, now is a chance for you to acknowledge that the environment is more important than yourself.
Kotchen, Matthew J. "Should We Drill in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge? An Economic Perspective." Sience Direct (2007). Www.ScienceDirect.com. Web.
Gelb, Bernard A. "ANWR Development: Economic Impacts." (2005). Www.cnie.org. Web.
Wednesday, March 3, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Hi, Gebe, the Karios you used is very appealing. The Current problems U.S as well as the whole world facing with is the power resource, and we Do Need Green revolution to solve this problem. I totally agree with you that profit could not be compared with our environment as well. However, as a common sense, everyone understands that we need to be friendly to our environment, but in fact, not everyone could put it into action. It might be people haven’t realized the seriousness of the environment. You may find more convincing evidences ( like Stats numbers) to show the importance of the environment problems.
ReplyDeleteOverall, good job! =]
Some things that I enjoyed about this project was the fact that it allowed me to pursue what I felt was important and worth writing about. The possibilities for this project were wide open and it really gave me an opportunity to write a short piece about something that I find interesting, not something that the professor found interesting, a nice change considering this is mostly what happens while you are in school. In doing this project I learned a bit about a topic that I found interesting, but had never really studied up until this point. It gave me the opportunity to look deeper into this topic and find some statistics and opinions that helped me to develop my own opinion. The most obvious rhetorical appeal that I used in this piece was kairos, I developed an introduction that showed why this subject is important because of the ways by which we live and operate. When revising this post I will take Flora’s advice which is to put in some more statistics about the subject, I feel as though this will strengthen my piece as well as develop a stronger ethos. Also, by listing stats that will back up my argument, my piece will become more persuasive and continue to show the importance to the reader.
ReplyDeleteGabe, this is a very informative, reflective post which shows you clearly know about the issue at hand. I would agree with Flora that you could post some statistics, perhaps showing how we get most of our oil from Canada, Mexico and Saudi Arabia which would in turn show how dependent we truly are on foreign oil and the necessity for a green revolution. I'd strongly suggest pointing out how the rest of the world is already part of the green revolution while the United States has fallen behind. Just this year alone China eclipsed Europe on manufacturing of green technology, if America doesn't get involved then ten years from now all of "our" green technology will still say the ever famous "Made in China." I appreciate that you cited your information as it's very helpful in case I wanted more information. Overall well done.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Gabe, for your post. I like how in your opening you validate in a way the position that you ultimately argue against--that is, you recognize the pressures that many Americans face and some of the root causes for why we might a very wasteful culture. But as I read that first paragraph, I would have almost predicted that you were going to argue in favor of drilling in Alaska, so as you revise, you might try to signal your stance earlier on (without losing your sense of understanding the other side of this argument). Near the end of your post, I wonder if you might also enhance your persuasiveness by spending bit more time emphasizing or describing what's so valuable about ANWR. Could you maybe include some additional examples of what makes this place so environmentally special? That might help you further strengthen your conclusion.
ReplyDelete